From CBC's Elliotte Friedman after talking to Mike Murphy from the NHL
"[Referee Mike] Leggo waves it off when the puck hits the post and starts to come to the net as a scramble develops. [In the NHL's video review room in Toronto] we're still looking at the puck off the post, then see the play with Leggo approaching net, putting the whistle in his mouth and he waves aggressively.
"The optics would have been better if we got him to put on the headset and asked what he was seeing... We spoke after the game, I told him it did go in, we probably would get some pushback and should have gotten him over [to the headset] for the optics of the review."
Interestingly, the review would have happened before the league office actually knew the puck was in the net. It's not uncommon to review shots off the post or wild scrambles near the line, but like San Jose's broadcast team (Buffalo's didn't show it), Murphy and his mates didn't realize it was a goal until after play resumed. A goal cannot count in that situation.
Despite all this, Murphy is adamant it was the right call under Rule 78.5.
"Had we called a goal against Buffalo it would have been wrong, because it shouldn't have been a goal," he said. "We should have done the headsets, because any controversy would have died. This type of play is not a rarity."
Now from me..
...you see Rule 78.5 states a goal shall be disallowed when,
(xii) When the Referee deems the play has been stopped, even if he had not physically had the opportunity to stop play by blowing the whistle.
The whole "well I meant to or I was intending to blow the whistle."
The NHL's version of a Cover Your .. Well you know.
Mike Murphy's explanation of Mike Leggo's reasons for not calling a call that should have counted doesn't come close to what I saw, but 10 people can watch a play and come up with 10 different versions of the event.
However one time I would love the NHL to "own it". Just one time admitting that they booted the call.
If you watched Tuesday nights broadcast of the Sharks game against Buffalo on Comcast Sportsnet California or saw the highlights later on you know that the Sharks got a raw deal in overtime. The problem is I’m still not sure how a winning goal in overtime went undetected by the on-ice officials and the video review officials. Here’s what I think happened.
About two minutes into overtime, with the score tied 4-4, the Sharks Tyler Kennedy fired a hard wrist shot past Sabres goalie Ryan Miller and it bounced off the far goal post. Referee Mike Leggo immediately and correctly waved his arms indicating no goal, but he did not blow his whistle nor did it seem he was about to. The puck then bounced back underneath Miller back into the crease. Then a diving Tommy Wingels poked it into the net. The overhead replay then clearly shows Buffalo defenseman Tyler Myers quickly kicking the puck back out of the net with his right skate and the puck was then frozen underneath Millers pad. Leggo then blew the play dead.
It seems to me that Mike Leggo never saw the puck enter the net and didn’t see Meyers quickly slide it back out with his foot/skate. I’m guessing that in Leggo’s mind there was nothing to review because he never saw a goal. Now of course, we know that there was a goal.
The next question is what happened to the video review process? As I understand it the video goal judge at SAP Center has a dedicated live feed of both the overhead goal camera and the NHL’s in-net camera. Both of those views clearly showed the puck entering the net. It is also my understanding that the NHL’s video control center in Toronto has exactly the same live feed of those two camera’s. But neither the in-arena video goal judge, nor the staff manning the NHL video control center noticed the puck going into the net. Once the ensuing faceoff occurred and overtime continued, no goal could be awarded.
A few moments later our Comcast crew, in reviewing the play, noticed the puck had crossed the line and then we aired our footage at the next stoppage of play.
In summary: The Sharks scored in overtime, the on ice officials didn’t see it and the in arena video goal judge didn’t see it on the live feeds, nor did his colleagues in Toronto. The NHL’s usually reliable process failed this time. It cost the Sharks a win and a point in the standings and I’m not sure how the hockey gods will even this one out.
I’m Randy Hahn
Here are a bunch of one-timers, a Baker's Dozen to be exact, to get the week started.
- If the standings don't say it loud enough then just ask the Winnipeg Jets this question, "So how's life in the Western Conference?".
- How can you not love Brent Burns ... looks like a caveman for a couple of months and then shaves his head and beard for charity and raises over $23,000.
- The emotion Dan Boyle showed after scoring the PP goal against Phoenix pretty much summed up how hard it was dealing with an injury that ultimately could have been a lot worse. Great to see you back Boyler!
- Justin Braun is leading the Sharks in the one non-scoring statistic that says a lot - TOI or Time On Ice. Braun's value is shown in his averaging 22:03 TOI per game, almost a minute and half more than Vlasic who is 2nd on the team with 20:37.
- Speaking of Braun and Vlasic, they are tied atop the NHL for plus/minus at a very impressive +12.
- Logan Couture is 2nd for forwards in the NHL in blocked shots with 18. It's an impressive stat because blocking shots is not fun and you are paying the price for your team, and that's what Logan Couture is all about.
- Drew wrote about it in his last blog but I wanted to comment on what an amazing coaching staff the Sharks have. They are smart, work so hard it's ridiculous and are all good people ... and they have fun at what they are doing. Awesome stuff! Here's the link to Drew's last blog.
- People say Joe Pavelski isn't a 3rd line center. I say "Yes he is"! If you have the best 3rd line center in the NHL what does that say about your depth?
- After the game vs Buffalo on Tuesday night the Sharks next five games are against Western Canadian teams. Vancouver comes to SAP Center on Thursday and they are a motivated team that is playing well right now. Then the Sharks hit the road for a five game, nine day road trip that starts in Winnipeg before heading to Calgary, Vancouver and Edmonton. Lots of double anthems coming up!
- The two teams with a better 5-5 F/A than the Sharks are Anaheim at 1.91 and Colorado at 1.87. The Sharks currently sit 3rd in the NHL tied with Minnesota with a 1.83 5-5 F/A.
- Are you asking yourself what the heck is 5-5 F/A? If not, go to next bullet point. If yes, then I am happy to help. 5-5 F/A is a team's average for scoring goals For in even-strength 5-5 situations versus having goals scored Against. If a team has scored 20 goals for 5-5 and has given up 20 goals against 5-5 then their ratio would be 1.00. So the higher the ratio, the better it is. The Sharks have scored 33 goals 5-5 this year and given up 18. So 33 divided by 18 is 1.83. Voila! This is an important stat because if teams are good 5-5 then they don't have to rely as much on special teams to win games.
- Three of the top four players in TOI for forwards in the NHL are on the same line and the Sharks will see them this Thursday at SAP Center. Ryan Kesler leads the way averaging 22:57 a game while Henrik Sedin is 2nd at 22:47. Third is Sidney Crosby at 22:37 followed by Daniel Sedin at 22:25. The top three forwards in regards to TOI for the Sharks are (where they are in TOI for forwards in the NHL): 1. Marleau 20:05 (30th) 2. Couture 19:38 (41st) 3. Pavelski 19:29 (44th).
- I am saving the best for last. This past Saturday my partner, the great Dan Rusanowsky, was inducted into the Bay Area Radio Hall of Fame. What an honor and accomplishment for Ruzzie who is a total pro and just a great person whose loyalty to the San Jose Sharks is nothing short of amazing. I am in my 9th year working with my fellow St. Lawrence University alum and I am proud to have worked with him for all these years. The longest anyone worked with Dan prior to my arrival was 4 years because often they left for a TV analyst position. Well I couldn't be happier and am honored to working with a Hall of Famer! Now I just want to hear Ruzzie make his greatest call of all ... "Sharks win The Stanley Cup!"
Mirco Mueller, the Sharks top draft pick, was born and raised in Switzerland, and his country is beginning to make more of an impression on the National Hockey League as the years go on.
As of today, there are seven Swiss skaters playing in the NHL, and the Sharks have faced three teams with Swiss natives on the roster: Vancouver (Yannick Weber), Calgary (Sven Baertschi and Reto Berra), and Montreal (Raphael Diaz).
Virtually all of the Swiss natives have come into the NHL since the 2000-01 season, when Reto Von Arx (Chicago), Thomas Ziegler (Tampa Bay), and Michel Riesen (Edmonton) all had cups of coffee at the big league barista. But there are two others (Hnat Domenichelli and Paul DiPietro) who are listed as Swiss by the NHL website, but who were born and raised in Canada, later gained Swiss citizenship, and played for the Swiss Olympic team. These two started their careers earlier, as did Simon Wheeldon, who was born in Vancouver, played briefly in the NHL in the late 1980’s, moved to Austria, played for the Austrian Olympic team, but who is listed as Swiss on the NHL website.
Berra is the most recent Swiss story. The goaltender made his NHL debut a memorable one, with a 42 save performance in a 3-2 overtime win against Chicago on Sunday night, and he’s the sixth goalie who was born in Switzerland to make it to the NHL.
For our final gaze at Switzerland’s contributions to the NHL, the goaltending leader is Jonas Hiller of Anaheim, who has 139 career wins and 26 shutouts. The points leader is Philadelphia’s Marc Streit, who has 292 points as of this writing.
But in San Jose, the Swiss focus is on Mueller, who currently plays for the Everett Silvertips of the WHL under coach Kevin Constantine. So far, in 15 games, Mueller is one of the leaders on the defense, and has 1-5-6 totals.
As with the case with California born-and-raised players, we’re starting to see the influence of other places, such as Switzerland. It’s an important and developing story about the growth of the NHL around the world.
This and that:
When talking Sharks hockey there seems to be a player who is often overlooked. The date was March 23rd, 1999. That’s when the Sharks made a deadline deal with Montreal that brought the Canadiens’ captain Vincent Damphousse to San Jose. Damphousse brought with him a winning pedigree and gave the team instant credibility. He was an elegant player whose style and flair should not be forgotten. The Sharks team that he joined in the spring of 1999 was a very average team, but his winning attitude and quiet leadership was much valued by the team in teal. Damphousse’s NHL career was outstanding. He played 1378 NHL games while notching 432 goals and 773 assists. The pinnacle of his career was winning the Stanley Cup in 1993 as Montreal enjoyed a magical run. During 5 ½ years with San Jose Vincent played 385 games and posted 92 goals and 197 assists. His career was outstanding and a case could be made that Vinnie belongs in the Hockey Hall of Fame. I remember Vincent as a classy guy who embraced the team and the community. He was a smooth skater, a great passer and was a remarkably smart player. Next time you talk Sharks hockey, don’t forget the Flying Frenchman, Vincent Damphousse.
There are 30 teams in the NHL and with that 30 NHL buildings. I’ve been fortunate enough to have been at all of them, plus a handful of retired rinks. Baseball/Football stadiums of the ’70s saw the advent of the ‘cookie cutter’ ballparks. Their artificial turf and circular seating configuration were quite unremarkable. It was hard to tell the difference from park to park. Was it Philadelphia, Pittsburgh or Cincinnati? Hockey should have learned but in the 1990s was the era of NHL ‘cookie cutter’ arena. Massive structures that valued private suites over seating of the common fans were being built at a rapid pace. Examples of rinks from this time are Chicago, Buffalo, Philadelphia, LA and Dallas. Luckily for Sharks fans SAP Center predated those buildings of the bland. Completed in 1993 and named the San Jose Arena, the Sharks South Bay home was a smashing success. Built on a human scale, the arena had and continues to have some of the best sightlines in the league. With a capacity of 17562, SAP Center provides perhaps the most intimate fan experience in the league. I speak to broadcasters and fans all across North America and they rave about the atmosphere, fan energy and proximity to the ice in San Jose. The last row of the upper bowl is both lower and closer than the first row of the upper bowl in most NHL rinks. Those who follow the Sharks closely and go to the games in person know exactly what I’m talking about.
The Sharks just completed an October to remember. During the 10th month 2013, San Jose posted a 10-1-2 record. Their 22 points is most in the NHL. 13 games into the season show 16 Sharks players have scored at least one goal. 8 different Sharks have a game-winning goals to their credit. Perhaps the most impressive stat is their +27 goal differential. The next closest teams are…Colorado +19, Toronto +16, Montreal + 14 and St Louis +13. Now it’s early, but these October points are every bit as important as points earned in March and April.
It starts right after a game and goes right up until the next game. It's the work that the coaches put in breaking down video, scouting opponents and putting into detail what will help carry the Sharks to success.
I will give you the play-by-play:
The team has just boarded the plane for the trip back to San Jose after a tough loss in Los Angeles.
Before the equipment is loaded into the cargo bay, Todd McLellan, Larry Robinson, Jay Woodcroft, Jim Johnson, Wayne Thomas and Brett Heimlich have their individual computers out watching video.
They all watch the scoring chances for and against from the game they just coached. They will also watch for plays both good (foundation plays) and bad (breakdowns) that need to be highlighted and corrected before the next game.
The next step for the respective coaches is to go to work getting ready for the next opponent. Larry Robinson may be scouting the next game while Jim Johnson is analyzing the special teams. While that is happening Jay Woodcroft is scouting the first game of the opponent a game away.
Depending on the schedule, the coaches try to scout a minimum of two games of an upcoming opponent. Very often because of their work ethic they get in three or four games.
Tomorrow morning the coaches will meet early, (before 7AM) and as a group breakdown the scoring chances and tendencies in the previous night's game.
Collectively they will discuss highs, lows, good plays, bad plays and top performers and players that need some extra time with the coaches in order to meet performance expectations. It is important that they do this together, so that everyone is on the same page.
In other words, the players are being held accountable, but in a very honest and positive, "we're all in this to get better" approach.
After the video they practice plan and head out on the ice and put the guys through a fast paced, intelligent skate. Once again, focusing on getting better, everyone on the same page, let's keep pushing forward mentality.
This tireless work ethic and dedication is not uncommon amongst NHL coaching staffs. In "The Show" the coaching staffs are at the top of their game like the players.
What is uncommon from the Sharks perspective is the fun this particular coaching staff has working with each other and the way they process/share information amongst each other and with the players.
I have been privy to the laughs, jokes and good natured chirping that goes on between them. But with the jocularity is a high level of respect for each other, a passion to succeed and a deep love of the game.
So as the Sharks enjoy one of the best starts in franchise history, let's remember to pat the coaches on the back for a job well done....and trust me their continuing on the job right now.
It’s finally here. Tonight the Sharks face the Los Angeles Kings. Is it rivalry night on the west coast? You bet it is. Debate all you want but the Sharks top rival is LA and the Kings top rival is San Jose.
A dozen games into the season the Sharks sit atop the Pacific Division with 21 points. The Kings are 5 points back in fourth place. It’s too early to try and figure out what the landscape will look like in April but the early returns for both teams are good.
They might have looked a little flat last night in a 3-1 loss in Phoenix but the Kings have a good team again. They’re only 16 months removed from winning the Stanley Cup and last season got to the Western Conference Final for a second straight season. And oh yes, the Kings are the team that knocked the Sharks out of the playoffs last spring.
If you think that fact is lost on the Sharks players who skated off the ice at Staples Center following a 2-1 loss on May 28th you would be incorrect. Who knows if both the Sharks and Kings will make the playoffs this season? Who knows if they’ll meet again if they do both qualify? But if you are a Sharks player, coach or member of management you went into the past off-season thinking about what it would take to get past the Kings, didn’t you? How do you beat LA in a 7 game series? How do you win on LA ice, something the Sharks failed to do in last seasons second round series.
Those questions can’t be answered until a future playoff meeting, but the message sending starts tonight. The Sharks want to show that their early season improvement is for real. The Kings want to maintain the upper hand on their northern rivals.
It’s the biggest game of the season, so far. The Sharks want to beat LA.
I think it's important to note that all 4 of those teams made the playoffs last year:
Boston - went to the Cup Finals losing to Chicago in 6 games Detroit - Lost in the 2nd round to eventual Cup Champs Chicago in 7 games Ottawa - Lost to Pittsburgh in the 2nd round Montreal - Lost to Ottawa in the 1st round
Goals For: 8
Goals Against: 4
Players injured, not playing: Boyle, Burns, Torres, Burrish, Havlat
Discipline and patience - those are two of the characteristics the Sharks showed in a defensive gem as the Sharks shut out the Red Wings at Joe Louis and won the game in the shootout.
Spectacular - the save Neimi made on Bertuzzi to secure the win.
Stifling - The Sharks did that to the Bruins out-shooting them 39-17 only to get a taste of their own 'stifling' medicine by Tukka Rask who stole the game for the hometown Bruins.
Buzzer beater - we see it in basketball all the time but not very often in hockey. Unfortunately for the Sharks, who were the last team in the NHL without a regulation loss, the Bruins scored with 0.8 seconds left to win the game 2-1.
Suffocating - that's what the Sharks did to Montreal's offense as the visiting Sharks shut out the Habs 2-0 on Hockey Night In Canada.
Chien chaud - the hot dogs in Montreal are terrific. If I've said it once I've said it a million times, it's all about the bun and they toast the buns there.
Gumption - what the Sharks showed as they played about 20 hours after an emotional win in Montreal to defeat the Senators 5-2.
Perseverance - Alex Stalock getting his 1st NHL start at the age of 26 after overcoming a career threatening injury.
On the flight home from Ottawa, it’s time to reflect on what has been a most eventful road trip for San Jose Sharks hockey. On this trip, the team found out a lot about itself and virtually all of it remains a very exciting sign for the prospects for the season.
Let’s look at the most important things that the Sharks found out about themselves on this little trip to the Eastern Time Zone. All of what they found relate to one word, “response,” and more specifically, “response to a variety of challenges by outstanding teams.”
It all began in Detroit, where the Sharks and their perpetual shooting gallery was met by the coach’s video preparations on the opposite side of the ice. Yes, the Detroit staff was ready for the Sharks, and what ensued was an intellectually-based chess match between Todd McLellan and Mike Babcock, a goaltending duel between Antti Niemi and Jimmy Howard, warm, soft, slow ice conditions, an irregularity in the Motor City, and a 65:00 of intense hockey where the Sharks were held to just 27 shots on goal and where Detroit mustered only 24.
Both goaltenders made some crucial stops, but none was more important than the one that Niemi made on Todd Bertuzzi in the shootout. With Logan Couture having just scored, all Niemi needed to do was stop the puck to get the win and when he was able to lift his right pad upward just enough to get Bertuzzi’s formidable attempt, the look on Bertuzzi’s face was priceless and the Sharks got out of town with two points in the standings.
On to Boston, San Jose simply dominated the action for, conservatively speaking, 59:30 of the 60:00. They outshot Boston 39-17 for the game, and forged ahead against the Bruins. But victory wasn’t to be: late in the second period, Jarome Iginla found a way to deflect one past Niemi for his first Bruins goal, and then, with 0.8 seconds left in the game, a David Krejci deflection of an Adam McQuaid shot from the point got past Niemi, and the Sharks lost for the first time in Boston since the Joe Thornton trade.
The question on everyone’s mind after that loss was, “How were the Sharks going to respond?” Their next matchup was in Montreal, on Saturday night, in front of an entire province and nation (on CBC television). All they did was skate with the speedy Canadiens stride for stride. They got a brilliant performance in all three zones from Logan Couture, who scored twice. The Quebec natives, Marc-Edouard Vlasic and Jason Demers, had terrific nights, and Niemi was solid again as the Sharks won, 2-0, only their third win ever in Montreal, and first in 11 years.
But what happened in the final three minutes of that game was truly incredible. Against a solid team, the Sharks made it impossible for the Canadiens to pull goaltender Carey Price in the third period. Montreal simply couldn’t get far enough up ice to do it. In the third period, the Sharks played essentially three lines and used Joe Thornton with James Sheppard and John McCarthy, who did an outstanding job when called upon to play great defensive hockey. With Vlasic and Justin Braun shutting things down, the Sharks simply put on a clinic that was incredibly impressive.
The very next day, San Jose had everything working against them: an afternoon start against a team that was rested and ostensibly motivated, given a 50-shot performance by the Sharks against them at SAP Center just a few weeks before. The Sharks were going with Alex Stalock in net for the first time, giving Niemi a game off after 11 straight starts.
What happened wasn’t the prettiest of games, but the Sharks also chose to show how it would respond to a satisfying, successful night. They didn’t have their legs, which was understandable, but Stalock had a great first NHL start with 38 saves, including 16 in the first period when the Sens really were going for the kill.
San Jose found out after the warmup that Matt Nieto was not going to be able to play, and although that looks like a short-term situation, it changed the plans for the evening. But Andrew Desjardins and James Sheppard came up with their first goals of the season, Tomas Hertl ended a goal-scoring drought, the Sharks scored in the opening 1:30 of the first and 3rd periods, Tommy Wingels scored a shorthanded goal, and Joe Pavelski finished off the Sens with a deflection on a give-and-go with Justin Braun, who continues to be mighty impressive.
All in all, the Sharks are showing that they are up for virtually any challenge, and every member of the team is making a contribution and commitment to the cause.
Now, it’s on to Los Angeles to finish the trip. The challenges will continue to mount, but so will the excitement.
This and that:
- The Sabres’ John Scott laid out a brutal hit on the Bruins’ Loui Eriksson Wednesday night. It’s another example a hit which must be policed and punished. Eriksson had clearly shot the puck into the offensive and was viciously blindsided the Bruins’ player. The targeting of the head cannot be permitted. The NHL and the NHLPA needs to work together on this topic to protect the players. The NHL should look at the sad stories emerging with players in the NFL.
- The Sharks added depth and toughness with the acquisition of forward Mike Brown from the Oilers for a 4th round draft pick. The Sharks are the 5th club that Brown has suited up for. Sharks fans will remember Brown from his 2 years in Anaheim. Brown is another American NHLer. He’s from Chicago and played college hockey for Red Berenson’s Michigan Wolverines.
- Antti Niemi’s shootout save on the Red Wings’ Todd Bertuzzi Monday night was one for the ages. Bertuzzi started right then to left attempting to out wait the Finish netminder, but Niemi stayed with it and while laying on his belly found a way to extend his right pad stealing a shootout goal and sealing a Sharks 1-0 victory over the Wings.
- For Sharks’ fans who just can’t get enough of their team, I have good news. This is the first season that the SJSharks.com producers will be on every road trip. Look for great pre and postgame video coverage of the players and members of the Sharks broadcast team. Content will be on almost every platform, SJSharks.com, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and more. The website’s production team is at every practice and game, home and away. Let us know what you think and what more you’d like to see.
- The current road trip is a special one. With stops in original six cities Detroit, Boston, Montreal along with hockey-crazed Ottawa, and winding it up with a rival game in LA, makes it a fun time to follow the Sharks.
- If you’d like to see photos from the Sharks road adventures, follow me on twitter @sharkstv.
- The Sharks depth is being tested with recent injuries to Dan Boyle and Brent Burns, not to mention the extended time out from Adam Burish and Martin Havlat. So far San Jose has successfully relied on production from those on the 3rd and 4th lines. Quality minutes are being logged by everyone on the roster.
- Last night’s game in Boston was a special one for several Sharks players. Rookie forward Freddie Hamilton skated on NHL ice for the first time against his younger brother Dougie. It was certainly a proud moment for the Hamilton family of Toronto, Ontario. 4 other Sharks returned to Boston ice after earning their college stripes in Beantown, Matt Nieto and John McCarthy skated at Boston University while Matt Erwin and Justin Braun wore the colors of Boston College. Boston gives Detroit a good run for the title of Hockeytown USA.